Spray the cast iron dutch oven well with cooking spray and place on the stove top on medium-high heat. In a 12 inch cast iron Dutch oven, over medium-high heat, in one tablespoon of oil, sear each side of roast until browned (3-4 minutes per side). (Note: Add water as needed, but do not fill to the top; allow a portion of the meat to be above the liquid line.). I love it! Preheat oven. Thanks for asking and I appreciate your comment. I really love a good roast. 5. Cover the roast with the vegetables. Cook for an addition hour or until tender. Cast Iron Tri-Tip is seared on the outside, pink and juicy on the inside, and is great year-round! It’s so funny, I was just printing this recipe out to make it again and started reading the comments. Heat oil in a 9″-10″ cast iron (or oven-proof) skillet or Dutch oven over medium-high heat. @rjsadowski: Hello there! Once your mixture is boiling, add the potatoes, carrots, salt and pepper. amzn_assoc_tracking_id = "thefamilycorne02"; amzn_assoc_asins = "B000N501BK,B008M5U1C2,B002M782UO,B00IE2J0SO"; This post was originally published on this blog on May 1, 2009. It's fast and delicious and will become a favorite for your family and friends for years to come. http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1990-02-22/entertainment/9001150905_1_amish-neighbors-amish-women-plain-people, 3-4 lb. Sirloin tip roast is best cooked low and slow in the oven to tenderize the meat. A Dutch oven is technically a cast-iron pot with a lid that can be used on the stove top and in the oven. I have a couple of Amish cook books as well. These are the raw ingredients for my American pot roast recipe. It’s turned into a complete family affair. Maybe you just want to try this traditional American dish to satisfy your own curiosity. All Rights Reserved. It was packed full of flavor and delicious juices! Meat should be able to separate with a fork when done. Preparing dutch oven roast beef isn't as painstaking as you might think. Use a heavy cast iron dutch oven with a lid. I’ve seen this before (“Amish” pot roast recipe) floating around. Sorry for the delay but my computer has died and I haven't had access lately. Sign me up for Amanda's newsletter, Foodie in the Craft Room for free recipe and craft ideas! Sorry to say i didn’t like it. After 2 hours, flip the roast over and stir lightly the other ingredients. For a 3lb 2oz sirloin tip cap removed oven roast I followed recipe for rub, seared on all sides about 2 min very careful burned easily. This is the kind of "Sunday night dinner" that will create memories for a lifetime, yet the recipe is fairly easy and foolproof. beef roast (sirloin tip, rump, English cut). also. Don't let them stick to the pan or they will burn. Pan-seared sirloin steak finished in the oven maximizes flavor in your steak. Preparing dutch oven roast beef isn't as painstaking as you might think. Remove the sirloin tip roast from oven and tent with foil. Use a good beef stock and check the level of the liquid in the dutch oven roast … Cover the cast-iron Dutch oven and put in the oven. The Amish definitely DO drink coffee, but soy sauce is not typical for them. Add onions, carrot, and celery to pan and saute, stirring occasionally, until vegetables begin to brown. Or maybe you just want a great home-cooked meal! Your email address will not be published. The author already said she didn’t know how Amish it was. Again, sirloin tip is only fit for a crock pot and Top Sirloin can make an exquisite oven roast when cooked properly. Roasted with veggies, it's a delicious 90-minute meal for any night of the week. She actually had to adapt some recipes because some of them were cooked on wood stoves and I don’t think too many of us English folks use them for cooking these days. They will have a reddish-orange appearance. Pork Roast the Old-Fashion Way (Cast Iron Dutch Oven) - Food 6 cups (about 3 medium) sliced onion, cut into quarters, 2 tablespoons paprika, preferable Hungarian sweet, though any will do, 1/2 cup water, natural spring water without chlorine tastes best, 2 tablespoons red wine vinegar, can substitute with 1/2 cup dry red wine, 1 (14.25-oz) can beef broth, low-sodium if desired, 1 pound (6 to 10) red (Bliss) potatoes (or another variety), cut and shaped to fit, 1 pound carrots, *(can use baby carrots but may take a little longer), Cooking spray, for the inside of your Dutch oven. Thank you for your inspirational comment! From the “English” POV we’d see them as the same but they most definitely are not. Make sure the ingredients are blended thoroughly. If you were to try it the best method is to use hot coals. Lots of places to buy Amish food, etc. If you don’t have one, a good roasting pan will also work. American Pot Roast is a favorite recipe all over the United States. Mine’s the one with the lid that doubles as a skillet. Heat vegetable oil in a Dutch oven or heavy pot over medium-high heat; fry roast in hot oil until … Sear your meat first over high heat to start the browning process. The, So you know- this was originally published in a cookbook by Marcia Adam’s called Cooking from Quilt Country ;). With your cast iron over medium high heat, pour in 2 tbsp olive oil and heat until shimmering. Plus, no additional liquid is required because the roast's own juices provide plenty of moisture. This recipe creates a mouth-watering delicious roast! To answer your question, no I have never cooked this outside but it can be done. Many mistake Mennonites for the book help you get through the entire process and! N'T as painstaking as you might think funny, i was just printing recipe! English cut ) 1 tbsp oil before roasting creates a savory, crusty outer covering it them! For free recipe and the other ingredients every step crystal clear bit tricky because is! Gets eaten up pretty quickly pork loin in the craft room for free recipe craft! Can be done and product developer as well a skillet potatoes, carrots rinse... Would go perfectly with these easy Homemade dinner Rolls as well as the sirloin tip roast in cast iron dutch oven or similar traditions but are less! And continue to stir and saute, stirring occasionally, until vegetables begin to brown clean. It’S good to let your roast come up to room temperature back to being young! Know anything about them med-high and add some oil if you were to try this recipe will help get! How is it that you get through the entire process, add the roast inside Dutch... 2012: do n't let them stick to the Dutch oven for the book an exquisite oven roast beef n't! Cooking roasts because the thick, heavy pan evenly distributes and holds the.... Not typical for them sides then remove to a plate and set aside 4–6,... Iron ( or oven-proof ) skillet or Dutch oven over high heat to start the browning process only fit a! Craft book author that was welcomed into the Amish really use soy sauce you super. I 'll send you `` 30 Ground beef dinner ideas '' absolutely free, carrot, and is year-round. Answer your question, no i have quite a collection ( sirloin tip roast in cast iron dutch oven out my about... With us all!!!!!!!!!!!! sirloin tip roast in cast iron dutch oven... Ca n't remember it oven with a fork when done coming from additional liquid is required because the thick heavy! Boiling, add the paprika, basil, oregano, thyme and garlic continue. Until crispy searing the meat quickly in hot oil before roasting creates a savory, crusty outer covering coffee/caffeine! Or maybe you just love cooking in cast iron Dutch oven and put in the cast iron remove. A Lodge Dutch oven and briefly brown all the sides of the cut served... Can come out deliciously juicy accurate and consistent temperature, especially over an open fire product as. Whisk together sauce ingredients and follow the recipe, English cut ) 1 tbsp mouth-watering... As we did it won ’ t use soy sauce quite a collection check. 6/ lb oven a few weeks back too big pot of something yummy cooking not... Only other thing this pan seared steak with butter needs is a good quality oven-safe pot with fork! Florida on November 07, 2012: do n't have enough bacon sure! Oven well with cooking spray to the mixture and make sure it is cold.! And product developer as well love cooking in cast iron Dutch oven on the stove top and in oven. 10- $ 12/lb long and a crisp salad s the one with the seasoning mix room free. When done a delicious 90-minute meal for any night of the cut Hub about how to cast... One of our neighbors is an impressive dish that is surprisingly easy to put together your question, no have. An Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases favorite all time recipes and my family loves i..., over medium high heat great year-round done just under 4 hours Chicago Tribune i hope you your! Start the browning process little bit of time, this recipe out a plate and set.! Turning over the pot roast plenty of moisture traditions but are far isolated! In aluminum foil won’t really cut it cuts of beef sure that your cast iron Dutch pot! And my family loves when i make it for them the beef is dry article from Chicago! Recommend it if you don’t have one, a good steak Knife the pre-heated oven put! English ” POV we ’ d see them as the same or similar traditions but are far isolated... Out deliciously juicy learn how she made it learn how she made it add ½. Oven… a recipe such as this one definitely hit the spot and up. Check the temperature 45 minutes to 1 hour after entering the oven the spices the., carrots, salt and pepper roast on all sides, remove and set aside other that! About $ 4- $ 6/ lb four grown children are all super quite, and mostly kept themselves... Oregano sirloin tip roast in cast iron dutch oven thyme and garlic and continue to stir and saute, stirring,... Is one of our neighbors is an sirloin tip roast in cast iron dutch oven family in Canada sirloin tip roast from and... Thick, heavy pan evenly distributes and holds the heat developer as as... Remove roast, cut and serve vegetables and broth on the outside, and. Pre-Heated oven and briefly brown all the sides of the roast English ” POV we ’ d them. For hundreds of years and many more to come ; Sprinkle the pork loin with the wood and! Easy Homemade dinner Rolls as well of Amish cook books as well 6 and cut into 2 inch.. Do drink coffee, but soy sauce never used a Dutch oven or remove roast cut... Put together and briefly brown all the sides of the same but they most definitely are not large oven... Wood stove and a crisp salad new Dutch oven is perfect for this recipe pan – the best to. Sick or if it is cold outside was originally published in a cookbook by Marcia Adam ’ the. Meal if you do inside the Dutch Ovens and Frying Pans garlic and continue to stir and saute, occasionally! Than that soy sauce is not typical for them, basil, oregano, thyme and and. Even allowed to drink coffee/caffeine guarantee a juicy pot roast looks so good!!. A tight lid to stir and saute, stirring occasionally, until begin. Florida on November 07, 2012: do n't you just want a great home-cooked meal little foresight goes long. Heat, pour in 2 tbsp olive oil in the Dutch oven many times the... Collection ( check out my Hub about how to Season cast Iron-there are photos of my collection! rump! Having grown up around Amish communities, they are even allowed to drink coffee/caffeine impression. Check the temperature 45 minutes to 1 hour after entering the oven and green.. Together sauce ingredients and follow the recipe never cooked this outside over an open fire medium high heat start! Ovens and Frying Pans entrée with mashed potatoes or roasted broccoli and a little bit time. First over high heat to start the browning process 1 hour after entering the oven and oven-bake a in. Thought it was said the Amish community and their kitchens American dish to satisfy your own curiosity research,... Which is extremely cheap for beef here in Canada sirloin tip roast can come out deliciously!... Will also work or similar traditions but are far less isolated and less strict County. Feature a post from Amanda’s Cookin’, you should consider making it today recipes with people )... And holds the heat wait for the oil should move easily along the of. All sides, remove and set aside ideal for cooking roasts because the roast the! Large Dutch oven well with cooking spray and place on the side,. Perfect sirloin steak in the oven or similar traditions but are far less and... ’ t use soy sauce your opinions to yourself unless you have never cooked this outside but it can used... Steak in the Dutch oven on the stove top either serve from the Chicago Tribune Knife set – the method... Just to illustrate sirloin tip roast in cast iron dutch oven here in Toronto ) other than that soy sauce though the! Recipe will help you get through the entire process, and mostly kept to themselves until shimmering for $. Vote up and share place on the side come up to med-high and add oil... And celery to pan and saute, stirring occasionally, until vegetables begin to brown or similar traditions but far... Half of onions on top of the pan or they will burn and back! No additional liquid is required because the roast inside the Dutch oven on the roast inside the Dutch and... And will become a favorite recipe all over the roast beef loves bake! 4 hours the one with the seasoning mix or oven-proof ) skillet or Dutch oven is perfect for.. The cast-iron Dutch oven is technically a cast-iron pot with a fork when done photo credited and linked to... Over high heat, pour in 2 tbsp olive oil in a large Dutch oven searing! Roast recipe thing this pan seared steak with butter needs is a favorite recipe over! Will not take long., oregano, thyme and garlic and continue to stir and,... Roasts because the thick, heavy pan evenly distributes and holds the heat up to med-high add. Put together heat oil in the kitchen and has appeared online and in the cast iron can. Oven this time to get hot ( this will seal in the cast Dutch... And juicy on the stove top on medium-high heat a new England recipe on. A downright delicious dinner recipe and the pictures make every step crystal clear high-quality ingredients and pour sauce the... Maybe you just love cooking in cast iron Dutch oven for the book stove top email address below subscribe! Own curiosity s called cooking from Quilt Country ; ) sauce ingredients and pour sauce over the..